警語
你必須達到所在地限制之法定飲酒年齡方可進入本站,請絕對不要酒後開車,傷害自己也傷害別人。

Date: Mar. 15, 2008
Place : SMWS台北會員室

PowerMagic兄終於發揮了, 還真的必須說這是相當有趣而且保證多數人都沒喝過的主題! 



Edradour 10yo (40%, OB, Tall Bottle, +/-2003)
C: Brown reddish, oil.
N: Smoky, citrus, toffee, mango, quite nice nosing
P: Medium heavy body, sweet, medium short finish.
C: 82 points. quite thick body, complex and not too much caramel. 這支酒是我提供的插花酒, 也不是我買的,是老姐的扶輪社朋友送我的酒.原來的禮盒還附了兩個威士忌杯. 由於是我開的酒, 我倒了第一杯, 反而沒感覺到後來大魔王拿給我聞的奶油香氣! 可能是喝太快了或是醒酒過程的因素. 不過我跟其他社員似乎有點不同的是我還比較喜歡這支,較沒有後面版本的焦糖甜膩



Edradour 10yo (40%, OB, dumpy bottle, +/-2005)
C: Brown, orange, watering.
N: more smoky, burned rubber, quite young and robust, more sherry note!
P: More caramel, 很膩!
C: 78 points. 與我在原廠喝到的印象比較接近. 可見得目前的風格大約就是如此.



Edradour 10yo 1995/2006 (57.4%, OB, SFTC, Sherry Butt#453, 1,030bts. 50cl)
C: Reddish, orange. 
N: Orange, very fruity, sherry note. smoky and rubber, boggy, light peat.
P: robust, very powerful, rush, with toffee and chocolate finish.
C: 80 points. Complex, layered, to robust but nice nose.  聞香很不錯, 但是入口過於猛烈而辛苦. 附帶一題的是MM Moniter把SFTC(Straight from the Cask)系列都歸為Signatoy裝瓶, 個人覺得應該不對, 不過反正Edradour就是隸屬Signatory旗下, 說起來也不算太離譜就是了.



Edradour 10yo 1993/2004 (59%, OB, C#03/422/3, 432 bts. Burgundy cask finish)
C: Brown orange.
N: Burned rubber, smoky. orange, boggy. not very wine cask feel. light nose.
P: Medium body, long finish, very good palate, quite un-expected.
C: 85 points. Palate is better than nose. finished very well. 這可能是少數我覺得喝起來比聞起來要好的Edradour, 絕大多數都是剛好相反.



Edradour 12yo 1994/2006 (58.4%, OB, SFTC, C#04/316/3, 1,0003 bts. Madeira Cask Finish)
C: Brown goldish.
N: Smoky, sweet, very malty.
P: Sweet, matured, god, smoky.
C: 85 poiint. Rounded, sweet, good for everyday drink, 相當輕鬆而無負擔的酒.



Edradour 12yo 1994/2006 (57.8%, OB, SFTC, C#04/157/5, 432 bts. Marsala Cask)
C: Light yellow, somewhat orange.
N: Very smoky, citrus, fresh, clear and nice.
P: Medium light body. finished short.
C: 84 points. Nosing is better than palate.



Edradour 24yo 1983/2007 (51.6%, OB, C#07/207, 692 bts. Port Finish)
C: Red, orange.
N: animal, sour, just like poo-poo!
P: Medium body, medium finish, terrible, very bad cask.
C: 68 points. 很失敗的一支作品, 屎味明顯, 完全不該問世的威士忌!



Edradour 11yo 1994/2006 (55.1%, OB, SFTC, C#05/997/2, 434 bts. Sauternas finish)
C: Red, orange.
N: Smoky, sulfer. sweet.
P: Medium body, medium finish.
C: 80 points. Not bad, but not very Sauternas. 以Sauternas finish來說算是好酒吧! 



Edradour NAS (51.8%, OB, Tokaji Cask matured 2007)
C: Brown.
N: Smoky, match box, very Tokaji finish.
P: Terrible palate, poor finish, Need to spit out!
C: 65 points. even worse the the port finish one. 好慘的一支酒!

kingfishertw 發表在 痞客邦 PIXNET 留言(1) 人氣()


留言列表 (1)

發表留言
  • 漢堡
  • Tokaji & Port

    K大對這兩支酒的評價真辛辣, 很少看見被您批成這樣的款項呢! 興隆路上有一間叫"將"的酒專, 價位不錯, 裡頭有一些Edradour, 若您有興趣可以去找找. 小弟在那邊以1200買到了Clynelish 14.
  • 謝謝資訊, 有機會再去晃晃, 發現自己現在越來越懶, 已經很久沒享受逛酒專的樂趣了! 應該不至於過於辛辣啦! 其實大多數的酒款都還高於我的期待呢!

    kingfishertw 於 2008/04/02 10:38 回覆

【 X 關閉 】

【PIXNET 痞客邦】國外旅遊調查
您是我們挑選到的讀者!

填完問卷將有機會獲得心動好禮哦(注意:關閉此視窗將不再出現)

立即填寫取消